Character
Rules
Events
Map
RP Points
Proplimits
Statistics
Steam Group
Members
Hall of Fame
Team
Bans
Blacklists
Warnings
Changelog
Content
04-23-2012, 10:59 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-01-2022, 01:01 AM by Fearless Community.
Edit Reason: Checked Encoding
)
Final review of unban appeal on Ryan!, filed 31/03/12
Primary player involved: Ryan! STEAM_0:0:40916370
Banning admin: Elder
Review of primary player's behavior potentially leading to ban: Ryan! has a very large history of bans, totalling 11. A significant number of these regard causing offense to others and disrespecting the admin team. I can put two and two together here, detailing ban 6344, in which Ryan! was banned for "Hate Speech". During that time his name had the tag [cigarette], which is very obviously offensive (He has one ban for calling someone this). Coupled with what Fulzy said on this thread about his homophobic comments towards Elder on another server, and my past experiences seeing Ryan! on the server, I know that there has been hate speech against homosexuals on the server, which is not tolerated at all. That alone is worthy of a significant ban. Whether he is called Karma or Ryan! does not matter in the slightest, it is the same person being banned in the end, and as such this does not make a difference in regards to the unban. Other bans include a count of RDM and using a molotov to randomly destroy a passiveRP event, which also constitutes failRP. The main issue I see here though is the disrespect towards admins and other players, for which Ryan! has several bans.
Review of admin ban procedure: All of the bans I can see on the ban list seem valid, with full proper reasoning. The admins making these bans have a good history of making bans previously. While Elder may have been slightly biased due to Ryan!'s homophobic comments and hate speech, it does not invalidate the ban for this matter - Any other admin would have done the same. While there have been unnecessary comments made towards Ryan! by one or two admins, it is also worth noting that those members or no longer part of the team, and that also that does not make it acceptable for Ryan! to do the same/worse to the admins - It is unacceptable on both sides. Elder is currently banned from our servers and forum, so any punishment towards him for this is moot.
Final unban appeal decision: DENIED - Bad history of aggression and disrespect towards admins and players, homophobic speech, as well as an extensive ban history over a long period of time, in which he should have had many chances to read and learn the rules properly and to improve his behavior.
Conditions of unban: Not applicable, unban appeal denied
Case closed by SA Faustie, 23/04/12
Primary player involved: Ryan! STEAM_0:0:40916370
Banning admin: Elder
Review of primary player's behavior potentially leading to ban: Ryan! has a very large history of bans, totalling 11. A significant number of these regard causing offense to others and disrespecting the admin team. I can put two and two together here, detailing ban 6344, in which Ryan! was banned for "Hate Speech". During that time his name had the tag [cigarette], which is very obviously offensive (He has one ban for calling someone this). Coupled with what Fulzy said on this thread about his homophobic comments towards Elder on another server, and my past experiences seeing Ryan! on the server, I know that there has been hate speech against homosexuals on the server, which is not tolerated at all. That alone is worthy of a significant ban. Whether he is called Karma or Ryan! does not matter in the slightest, it is the same person being banned in the end, and as such this does not make a difference in regards to the unban. Other bans include a count of RDM and using a molotov to randomly destroy a passiveRP event, which also constitutes failRP. The main issue I see here though is the disrespect towards admins and other players, for which Ryan! has several bans.
Review of admin ban procedure: All of the bans I can see on the ban list seem valid, with full proper reasoning. The admins making these bans have a good history of making bans previously. While Elder may have been slightly biased due to Ryan!'s homophobic comments and hate speech, it does not invalidate the ban for this matter - Any other admin would have done the same. While there have been unnecessary comments made towards Ryan! by one or two admins, it is also worth noting that those members or no longer part of the team, and that also that does not make it acceptable for Ryan! to do the same/worse to the admins - It is unacceptable on both sides. Elder is currently banned from our servers and forum, so any punishment towards him for this is moot.
Final unban appeal decision: DENIED - Bad history of aggression and disrespect towards admins and players, homophobic speech, as well as an extensive ban history over a long period of time, in which he should have had many chances to read and learn the rules properly and to improve his behavior.
Conditions of unban: Not applicable, unban appeal denied
Case closed by SA Faustie, 23/04/12