+- Fearless Forums (https://fearlessrp.net)
+-- Forum: CityRP Server (https://fearlessrp.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Forum: Suggestions (https://fearlessrp.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: Finished (https://fearlessrp.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+---- Thread: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule (/showthread.php?tid=69794)
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - edgie - 03-27-2016
(03-27-2016, 05:09 PM)Infernaw Wrote: Sometime during last year, we tried this out and it went to straight sh*t and was reimplemented to becoming against the rules again.
That's because as mentioned above, many people are too immature to roleplay it in a good way, and will just abuse it and call it "RP & IC" just to cover themselves.
Various types of discrimination are not allowed in many games for a reason. We should stick to that aswell.
in what way did you try it? did you remove the rules/make an announcement?
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Infernaw - 03-27-2016
(03-27-2016, 05:11 PM)shortcat Wrote:(03-27-2016, 05:09 PM)Infernaw Wrote: Sometime during last year, we tried this out and it went to straight sh*t and was reimplemented to becoming against the rules again.
That's because as mentioned above, many people are too immature to roleplay it in a good way, and will just abuse it and call it "RP & IC" just to cover themselves.
Various types of discrimination are not allowed in many games for a reason. We should stick to that aswell.
in what way did you try it? did you remove the rules/make an announcement?
This was when I had resigned but visited now and then. There should be some old thread about it.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Azog - 03-27-2016
Guys, I am not talking about going full KKK-mode going around screaming "kill all n*****s", burning crosses, or getting a new outfit to match it all.
I just think using some slurs should not be punishable since it only deepens the role play, and the character you play.
And to keep this rule only because someone might get offended? Utterly stupid. Someone will always be offended by something.
Even if you get offended IRL, get over it, stop being so sensitive behind your monitor.
Nobody knows what ethnicity the other players have, I do not see the problem that somebody may choose to refer to your model IC as a "chinese motherfucker" in a negative way.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Infernaw - 03-27-2016
The problem is not the slurs, the problem is the playerbase that will just overuse it with no actual RP background whatsoever.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Avgar - 03-27-2016
As far as I know when the rule was in place there were no reported cases of over-abusing the rule IC, nor do I remember anyone going full KKK mode. The rule was only reverted after the split by Soul.
With this said, I find it limiting to disallow even a little bit of racism or sexism IC. I'm not for allowing sexual abuse or harassment, but being, for example, exclusive in your role play (such as not accepting people into your gang based on their race or sex) should be allowed.
+ Support with certain restrictions, such as requiring a deeper RP background to be racist or sexist (mafia, gangsters, etc.)
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - summotion - 03-27-2016
(03-27-2016, 05:25 PM)Avgar Wrote: +Support with certain restrictions, such as requiring a deeper RP background to be racist or sexist (mafia, gangsters, etc.)
I remember when I used the "N Word" as part of RP radio chat and got banned for a day... only ban to this date.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Lesanka - 03-27-2016
+ Support
Of course it will never be allowed OOC.
But IC, it makes sense. I roleplay because I enjoy rich stories and having to make every character censored and politically correct takes away from a deep dramatic roleplay. Some of the most celebrated movies are full of sexism (The Godfather). That doesn't make it a bad movie. We don't have to support it in real life, it just adds to the roleplay.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Demoman - 03-27-2016
-Support. Don't see how this will make RP feel any better whatsoever, just unnecessary.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Zecon - 03-27-2016
+support
When the rule was initially implemented it was this,
"5.7 While you may be racist, sexist, and discriminatory IC, do not do this to excess or if it doesn’t fit your character’s roleplay. These actions must under no circumstances carry over to OOC."
which is worded in such a way that it meant it couldn't be abused, and it wasn't, it all worked well and I don't see why it was removed.
Your points are also good and the examples given back a good argument.
RE: Abandon IC Racism&Sexism rule - Infernaw - 03-27-2016
(03-27-2016, 10:24 PM)Zecon Wrote: +support
When the rule was initially implemented it was this,
"5.7 While you may be racist, sexist, and discriminatory IC, do not do this to excess or if it doesn’t fit your character’s roleplay. These actions must under no circumstances carry over to OOC."
which is worded in such a way that it meant it couldn't be abused, and it wasn't, it all worked well and I don't see why it was removed.
Your points are also good and the examples given back a good argument.
If that's how it is then +Support.